Effects of Conventional Therapy on Quality Of Life in CMT Disease Review and Meta-Analysis

Objectives: Up to now, only symptoms of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease can be treated. This work investigates which therapy is the most effective in Quality of Life in Charcot-Marie-Tooth. Methods: A literature research was conducted (search terms “Whole Body Vibration” or “WBV” or “Exercise” or “Rehabilitation” and “Charcot Marie Tooth” or “CMT” or “Hereditary Neuropathy” or “HMSN”) in five online databases. Inclusion: Publications from January 1990 to April 2022. Exclusion: No conventional treatment or Charcot-Marie-Tooth. Methodological quality: assessed by PEDro score. Effect sizes: calculated by Standardized Mean Differences and 95 % Confidence Intervals. Results: Of the 5,941 publications found, 17 focused conventional treatment for Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease of whom four had a good quality and investigated Quality of Life. No study investigates Whole Body Vibration. There is no effect (SMD = .29) in health related Quality of Life, a low effect (SMD = -.42) in Activities of Daily Living favoring experimental groups and no effect (SMD = .13) in Disability favoring control groups. Conclusions: These interventions cannot improve Quality of Life in Charcot-Marie-Tooth. Since no studies investigated "Whole Body Vibration" in Charcot-Marie-Tooth, this should be done as well as a motor ability training program. Such studies are in planning.


Introduction:
Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) is the most common neurogenetic disease. Between 20 and 30 persons per 100,000 of population are affected. It is mostly an autosomal-dominant hereditary condition. Therefore, there are clusters in individual families. In most cases, the cause is a mutation on chromosome 17. CMT is a hereditary disease of peripheral nerves. The nerve cell axon, the insulating myelin layer is damaged by a gene mutation. The myelin acts like plastic insulation around an electrical cable. In the disease, saltatory conduction of excitation, i.e., the transmission of nerve impulses in peripheral nerves, is impeded. As a result, commands from the brain do not reach the muscles or do not reach them properly. Denervation results in weakness and degradation of the affected muscles. Typical early symptoms include weakness or paralysis of the foot and lower leg muscles, which can lead to difficulty lifting the foot and a high-heeled gait with frequent stumbles or falls. Affected individuals also have balance problems. Foot deformities are also common in CMT. As the disease progresses, weakness and atrophy in the hands can cause difficulty with fine motor skills. Degeneration of sensory nerve axes can lead to a decreased ability to feel heat, cold and tactile sensations. Proprioception is often diminished in people with CMT. The condition can also cause curvature of the spine (scoliosis) and hip displacement. Many people with CMT develop contractures, which prevents joints from moving freely. Muscle spasms are common. Nerve pain can range from mild to severe. Some people rely on foot or leg braces or other orthopedic devices to maintain mobility. Progression of symptoms is gradual. The gene mutations in CMT are inherited in three different patterns: autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive and X-linked, all of which are linked to a person's chromosomes (1;2). There is currently no cure for CMT, but physical and occupational therapies, orthopedic devices, and orthopedic surgery can help sufferers manage the disabling symptoms of the disease. In addition, people with severe nerve pain may be prescribed pain-relieving medications. It is important to maintain mobility, flexibility and muscle strength. Starting a treatment program early can delay or reduce nerve degeneration and muscle weakness before disability occurs. Physical therapy includes strength training, stretching, and moderate aerobic exercise. A specific exercise program prescribed by a doctor can help improve endurance and maintain overall health. Many people with CMT need orthotics and other orthopedic devices to help maintain daily mobility and prevent injury. Bandages can help prevent ankle sprains by providing support and stability during activities such as walking or climbing stairs. Thumb splints can help with hand weakness and loss of fine motor skills. Such aids should be used before disability "occurs" because they can prevent muscle strain and reduce muscle weakness. Some people with CMT opt for orthopedic surgery to treat severe foot and joint deformities, improve walking ability, and relieve pain. Occupational therapy involves learning new ways to manage activities of daily living (2). A special form of exercise therapy is "Whole Body Vibration" (WBV) training. Many positive effects on various parameters have been reported for WBV, such as increased muscle activity, improved posture, and improved blood circulation in the legs (3;4;5;6;7). WBV is used since a few years in the exercise therapy for neurological diseases, such as stroke, Parkinson's disease or in diabetic neuropathy, as a few review can show (8;9;10). There are few side effects and contraindications known (11;12). Since WBV is such a smooth form of therapy, it could also be used for CMT.
Many studies have already been conducted to understand the positive effects of different treatment methods (exercise therapy, orthosis etc.) in CMT patients (13;14;15). Therefore, in this study it is aimed to understand which method is the most effective in the treatment on different aspects of Quality of Life in CMT.

Materials and methods:
This work followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. A literature search was performed using PubMed, PEDro, OVID, Cochrane Library and Science Direct databases using the search terms in combinations "Whole Body Vibration" or "WBV" or "Exercise" or "Rehabilitation" and "Charcot-Marie-Tooth" or "CMT" or "Hereditary Neuropathy" or "HMSN". Only original studies that investigated such conventional treatment for CMT patients were included. All publications from January 1990 up to April 2022 were included. There were no limitations in language, age of participants, or study characteristics (e.g., vibration frequency, single session, or long term). Studies that did not have WBV as a treatment or CMT as the treated disease, or animal participants were excluded. The PEDro score was used to determine methodological quality of the included studies. Selection and data collection were conducted by both authors. The methodological criteria were evaluated among both authors. In the case of disagreement, results were discussed and consent was found. RevMan 5.4 software was used for the metaanalysis. Funnel plots using the Egger test for publication bias were created (16). Standardized mean differences (SMD) and their 95%-confidence intervals (CI) were calculated, and classified as small (SMD > 0.3), moderate (SMD > 0.5), and large (SMD > 0.8) effects (17). SMD and CI are presented as forest plots. Random-effects model meta-analyses were also used, as the effects varied across studies. I 2 was used to assess heterogeneity between studies because I 2 can be calculated and compared across meta-analyses of different study sizes and types and can included different types of outcome data. The magnitude of heterogeneity was categorized into the following categories: low heterogeneity (I 2 =25%), moderate heterogeneity (I 2 =50%), and high heterogeneity (I 2 =75 %) (18;19). International Journal of Medical Science and Clinical Invention, vol. 09, Issue 07, July 2022 The following outcomes to assess different aspects of Quality of Life are used for the meta-analysis: Results: Table 1 provides the results of the searching strategy using the mentioned search terms. Table 1: Results of the searching strategy using the search terms "Whole Body Vibration" or "WBV" or "Rehabilitation" and 'or "Exercise"'"Charcot-Marie-Tooth" or "CMT" or "Hereditary Neuropathy" or "HMSN". The figure 1 presents the PRISMA flow diagram of the study process.

Combination of search terms Number of publications found
A total of 5,941 publications were identified in the initial literature search. After title screening, 1,989 duplicates and 3,104 publications that did not investigate CMT or conventional therapy for CMT were removed. Following the screening process, 82 publications remained, of which were 17 original studies with human participants. Table 2 provides an overview of the 17 included publications and their findings.  (39;40), one of physiotherapy (13) and one of dancing program (28). The person samples range from "s" for "ranges" = 8 (40) to n = 60 (27). Intervention duration range from single session (28) to 40 weeks (36). Most of the studies have a duration of 12 weeks (13;14;29;30;34;35;37;39;40). Methodological quality: Five studies are described as "good" (27;32;33;37;39) and can be considered to be included into a meta-analysis. Four of them investigate the effects of conventional therapy methods on different aspects of Quality of Life (27;32;33;39) and are included into meta-analysis. The complete overview of the methodological quality of the included studies, using the PEDro score, can be found in the following table 3. International Journal of Medical Science and Clinical Invention, vol. 09, Issue 07, July 2022  *0: criterion not fulfilled; 1: criterion fulfilled. The items are listed as follows: 1: eligibility criteria were specified; 2: subjects were randomly allocated to groups or to a treatment order; 3: allocation was concealed; 4: the groups were similar at baseline; 5: there was blinding of all subjects; 6: there was blinding of all therapists; 7: there was blinding of all assessors; 8: measures of at least one key outcome were obtained from more than 85% of the subjects who were initially allocated to groups; 9: intention-to-treat analysis was performed on all subjects who received the treatment or control condition as allocated; 10: the results of between-group statistical comparisons are reported for at least one key outcome; 11: the study provides both point measures and measures of variability for at least one key outcome; Total score: each satisfied item (except the first) contributes 1 point to the total score, yielding a PEDro scale score that can range from 0 to 10. Level of evidence: 6 or more of "good" quality, 4-5 of "fair" quality, and below 4 of "poor" quality.     (39) included here has nearly no effect, and favors depending from the outcome once experimental and twice in a very low degree control group. In the case of the VAS, it should be noted that criterion validity is questionable (43). Thus, it is not ensured that this scale really captures the severity of pain. Thus, the results of this study should not be taken into account, which would increase the overall effect size in favor of the experimental group. Highest effect favoring experimental group was found for CMTES (39), the highest effect favoring control group for CMTPedS (27). However, the tests that were used here are all questionnaires, so there is a lot of subjective latitude here, since the patients were asked to fill them out and there was no third-person evaluation. However, it can also be assumed that the intervention duration at Burns' study (27) was too long and thus an opposite effect was produced by fatigue/ overtraining of the patients in the experimental group (44). For the CMTPedS, it should be noted that it has only been validated with a relatively small sample (23 (27). In addition, it could be assumed that endurance training has a more positive effect than strength training, since endorphin response is increased after endurance training, among other things (45) However, it can also be assumed that the intervention duration at Burns' study (27) was too long and thus an opposite effect was produced by fatigue/overtraining of the patients in the experimental group (44).

Conclusions:
It seems that the interventions studied are not successful enough to improve the different aspects of Quality of Life in CMT. This could be due to the type of intervention, but also to the training parameters (e.g. intensity or frequency). It is also possible that the promotion of a single motor ability is not sufficient and that a program needs to be created that promotes all motor abilities (strength, endurance, speed, coordination, flexibility). Another rationale would be that because of the causes of CMT, such treatment does not work

Future directions:
In any case, to improve the different aspects of Quality of Life of CMT patients, further studies must follow. Since no studies on the effectiveness of whole body vibration on the symptoms of CMT are available so far, this gentle method should be investigated as soon as possible, since good results have already been achieved here in other neurological diseases. In addition, the effectiveness of a comprehensive training program that promotes all motor abilities should also be examined. Such studies are in planning.

Supporting information:
The PRISMA Checklist.